You Got Your Morality In My Fiction!
Posted: October 5th, 2010, 4:27 pm
I have to confess something: I'm shallow. When it comes to entertainment, I want it flashy, bright, and explode-y. If it can be described as "touching", "moving", or (heaven forbid) "life-changing", I'm completely disinterested. My idea of a perfect movie would be one written by Joss Whedon and directed by Michael Bay. There'd be lots of clever, snappy dialogue and deep characterization, then something would blow up and hot people would run past the camera in slo-mo. I'd be in movie heaven.
When it comes to books, my tastes aren't much different. I don't want to read something with a "point". I better not get to the end and feel like Yakko Warner will be spinning the Wheel of Morality so he can tell me what I should have learned from your story. It's not that I have anything against people learning decent morals, it's just that I don't want to be force-fed it by someone who thinks my leisure time is their pulpit time.
It's like when General Mills started putting health labels on their cereals. Look, when I'm buying Cocoa Krispies, I don't want to know there are vitamins in it. If I wanted vitamins, I wouldn't be eating Cocoa frickin' Krispies. You know what they should do? They should take out the vitamins. "Now With Fewer Nutrients," that's what the box should say. I'd eat two bowls a day.
I mean, I'd use soy milk. I'm in my 40s now and have to pay some attention to my health. But I digress.
The point is, I don't want vitamins in my sugary cereal, and I don't want spiritual vitamins in my leisure reading, either. I want great characters with intriguing stories, I want shocking adventures and complex villains. I do not want a treatise on feminism, the corruption of power, the misuse of our planet's limited marmot supply, or the evils of self-photography via cell phone cameras.
Now if it happens that your intriguing and shocking tale involves corrupt feminists or whatever, fine. But don't force it. Because I can tell, and so can every other reader, and we didn't plop down our $8 (or $12.99 if you have a Kindle, but that's another rant) for you to lecture us like we're a schoolroom of naughty children who need to be chided.
Good characters fighting for what they believe in – whether they're chasing rogue spies, trying to get the kids through another day, or rounding up a pack of mutant werewolves – will inevitably display positive moral traits. If they're people we're going to want to spend time with and stories that resonate, there will be examples to follow and examples to learn from, not because the author tried to put "a message" in the writing, but because that's how stories that work do work. Just tell me a great story, and let the morality take care of itself.
Seriously, though, we should do something to help the marmots.
----------
Bio: Jessa Lynch is a will-be fantasy novelist, farm owner, and dog person still trying to adjust to the idea of blogging. Her brand-new website can be found at http://www.jessalynch.com, and you can purchase a stuffed marmot on a skiboard at http://www.marmots.org to help save the marmots.
When it comes to books, my tastes aren't much different. I don't want to read something with a "point". I better not get to the end and feel like Yakko Warner will be spinning the Wheel of Morality so he can tell me what I should have learned from your story. It's not that I have anything against people learning decent morals, it's just that I don't want to be force-fed it by someone who thinks my leisure time is their pulpit time.
It's like when General Mills started putting health labels on their cereals. Look, when I'm buying Cocoa Krispies, I don't want to know there are vitamins in it. If I wanted vitamins, I wouldn't be eating Cocoa frickin' Krispies. You know what they should do? They should take out the vitamins. "Now With Fewer Nutrients," that's what the box should say. I'd eat two bowls a day.
I mean, I'd use soy milk. I'm in my 40s now and have to pay some attention to my health. But I digress.
The point is, I don't want vitamins in my sugary cereal, and I don't want spiritual vitamins in my leisure reading, either. I want great characters with intriguing stories, I want shocking adventures and complex villains. I do not want a treatise on feminism, the corruption of power, the misuse of our planet's limited marmot supply, or the evils of self-photography via cell phone cameras.
Now if it happens that your intriguing and shocking tale involves corrupt feminists or whatever, fine. But don't force it. Because I can tell, and so can every other reader, and we didn't plop down our $8 (or $12.99 if you have a Kindle, but that's another rant) for you to lecture us like we're a schoolroom of naughty children who need to be chided.
Good characters fighting for what they believe in – whether they're chasing rogue spies, trying to get the kids through another day, or rounding up a pack of mutant werewolves – will inevitably display positive moral traits. If they're people we're going to want to spend time with and stories that resonate, there will be examples to follow and examples to learn from, not because the author tried to put "a message" in the writing, but because that's how stories that work do work. Just tell me a great story, and let the morality take care of itself.
Seriously, though, we should do something to help the marmots.
----------
Bio: Jessa Lynch is a will-be fantasy novelist, farm owner, and dog person still trying to adjust to the idea of blogging. Her brand-new website can be found at http://www.jessalynch.com, and you can purchase a stuffed marmot on a skiboard at http://www.marmots.org to help save the marmots.